Skip to Main Content

EDUC 379A: Educational Psychology

Instructor: Diana Fenton

Scholarly vs. Popular Sources

  • Scholarly sources contain in-depth research
  • Scholarly sources are created by experts and are peer reviewed by other experts in the field
  • Scholarly sources always include a bibliography
  • Examples include: articles in academic journals (i.e. in library databases), books published by university presses

  • Popular sources cover broad, general interest topics
  • Popular sources are often entertainment, information or news focused
  • Popular sources are not peer reviewed
  • Popular sources often do not have a bibliography
  • Examples include: standalone dictionary or encyclopedia entries, newspaper articles, magazine articles

Identifying what constitutes a scholarly article can be tricky. Here are some tips for identifying scholarly works in library databases:

  • Tags in databases that say "peer-reviewed" or "scholarly journal" or "research article"
  • Material types in databases may say "research article" or "scholarly article"
  • Look for academic or university publishers (e.g. Duke University Press)
  • Do a bit of digging on the journal title and its requirements for peer review. Does it require a peer review process for article submission? Does the journal identify which articles are scholarly or peer reviewed?

When in doubt, reach out!
Your professor can clarify what they require for the assignment and a librarian can help you identify if you're on the right track.

Library Databases